First, Do No Harm
23 Jun 2017

Even though medical manslaughter is rare in Australia, two recent cases have highlighted that doctors are not immune from criminal charges for negligent care.
Former obstetrician, Graeme Reeves, was found not guilty of the manslaughter of patient Kerry Ann McAllister despite a failure to diagnose a severe infection causing her death. In his findings, District Court Judge Peter Zahra indicated that while Mr Reeves’ care was negligent, he did not believe Ms McAllister’s death was the result of gross criminal negligence.
In another recent case, a former midwife has been charged with two counts of manslaughter following the death of two babies during home births. Lisa Barrett was reprimanded by the SA Health Practitioners Tribunal in 2014, and the AHPRA Register of Practitioners indicates her registration was cancelled permanently in March 2014. Ms Barrett has been granted conditional bail following an appearance in the Adelaide Magistrates Court.
While the threshold for medical manslaughter is high, these cases are a reminder that if a negligent act results in the death of a patient, and the degree of negligence is proven to be gross or culpable, it could result in a criminal conviction.
This blog contains general information only. We recommend you contact your medical defence organisation or insurer when you require specific advice in relation to medico-legal matters.
A health practitioners guide to social media
What are the laws and guidelines that impact social media for practitioners?
22 Jul 2025
Patient Autonomy in Australian Medical care
Do we really support patient autonomy in the decision-making process?
22 Jul 2025
Practicalities of Medicare
Do you understand the Medicare system and are you confident that your billing processes comply with requirements?
22 Jul 2025
Understanding changes to the Fair Work Act
What are the changes to the Fair Work Act and what is my role?
22 Jul 2025