DePuy Successfully Defends Class Action

07 Jun 2018

Deborah Jackson

by Ms Deborah Jackson

Judge's gavel

The UK High Court has ruled in favour of the defendant, DePuy, in the DePuy Pinnacle ULTAMET metal on metal hip litigation. This decision could have a far reaching impact on the development of new medical products.

In the class action against DePuy, 312 individual claimants alleged an adverse reaction to metal wear debris generated by their prostheses, necessitating revision surgery.

The High Court considered the test of a ‘defect’ in a new product designed to improve previous generations of products. The Court provided an extensive analysis of the failure rates of the product. Her Honour found there was insufficient evidence to establish that the ULTAMET had a worse failure rate than was expected of a comparator at the time, or the actual failure rate of a comparator.

The claimants argued that the ‘defect’ was the known and widely publicised tendency of the product to produce metal wear debris which might cause an adverse reaction in some patients, such as immunological reactions which could lead to bone and/or soft tissue damage and failure of the prosthesis.  

DePuy successfully argued that a known consequence does not equate to a defect, and a comparison to a new product should be made in relation to what is on the market at the time.

The judge was scathing of the ‘hysterical media reporting’ which contained no scientific research to support their assertions. She determined that ULTAMET was a well-designed product with many positive engineering characteristics, and that a known and inherent characteristic of a product does not constitute a risk.

This decision supports new technologies and innovation. The willingness of the Court to consider the benefits of the product is a positive result for manufacturers.


This blog contains general information only. We recommend you contact your medical defence organisation or insurer when you require specific advice in relation to medico-legal matters.



Doctors Let's Talk: Get Yourself A Fricking GP

Get yourself a fricking GP stat! is a conversation with Dr Lam, 2019 RACGP National General Practitioner of the Year, rural GP and GP Anesthetics trainee, that explores the importance of finding your own GP as a Junior Doctor.


25 Oct 2022

Systematic efforts to reduce harms due to prescribed opioids – webinar recording

Efforts are underway across the healthcare system to reduce harms caused by pharmaceutical opioids. This 43-min recording of a live webinar, delivered 11 March 2021, is an opportunity for prescribers to check, and potentially improve, their contribution to these endeavours. Hear from an expert panel about recent opioid reforms by the Therapeutic Goods Administration and changes to the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme. 

Diplomacy in a hierarchy: tips for approaching a difficult conversation

Have you found yourself wondering how to broach a tough topic of conversation? It can be challenging to effectively navigate a disagreement with a co-worker, especially if they're 'above' you; however, it's vital for positive team dynamics and safe patient care. In this recording of a live webinar you'll have the opportunity to learn from colleagues' experiences around difficult discussions and hear from a diverse panel moderated by Dr Kiely Kim (medico-legal adviser and general practitioner). Recorded live on 2 September 2020.