Blogs

Court Clarifies Vaccination Position

04 Jan 2018

Julian Walter 110x137

by Dr Julian Walter

Doctor speaks with mother and child

The Medico-legal Advisory service is frequently contacted about disputes involving immunisation of children. GPs and other healthcare providers are often the ‘meat in the sandwich’ trying to balance the best interests of the child against conflicting parental consent (sometimes one consenting, one refusing).

A recent Supreme Court of Victoria appeal of an earlier Children’s Court decision is important because the index case is part of a growing number of decisions that demonstrate the willingness of Courts to find that immunisation is in the best interests of a child, despite the objections of the parents. In this case the children were in Departmental care and both parents refused consent for immunisation. The case demonstrates how political will and legislative change can assist in ‘best interests’ considerations.

‘No Jab No Play’ and ‘No Jab No Pay’ policies are evidence of increasing political will to ensure that herd immunity rates remain high. In NSW, ‘No Jab No Play’ legislation applies from 1 January 2018, similar to laws already in place in Victoria and Queensland.

If you are faced with difficult situations involving consent for the immunisation of children, don’t hesitate to contact our Medico-legal Advisory Service on 1800 011 255.

 

This blog contains general information only. We recommend you contact your medical defence organisation or insurer when you require specific advice in relation to medico-legal matters.

 

Library

Doctors, Let's Talk: Setting Boundaries At Work

A conversation with Nicola Campbell, Psychiatry Registrar, that explores the necessity of setting professional boundaries as a Junior Doctor.

Podcasts

07 Dec 2022

Doctors, Let's Talk: Your Support Network Is Your Net-Worth

A conversation with Nidhi Krishnan, Paediatric Registrar, that explores the value of building a strong network as a Junior Doctor.

Podcasts

07 Dec 2022

Doctors, Let's Talk: Are Retreats Worth The Money?

A conversation with Dr Emily Amos, General Practitioner, International Board Certified Lactation Consultant, and registered mindfulness teacher, that explores the utility of mindful retreats and self-care among Junior Doctors.

Podcasts

07 Dec 2022

Doctors, Let's Talk: Is Quitting Medicine Ever The Answer?

A conversation with Dr Ashe Coxon, General Practitioner, career counsellor, and founder of Medical Career Planning, that explores the issue of dealing with career uncertainty as a Junior Doctor.

Podcasts

07 Dec 2022